Anime SOTW 1

[WindWaker]

Rules:
-vote for the sigs that best represents the theme
-vote for 2 sigs. (If u vote for A and B, then if u Vote A first, A gets 2 points, then u vote B after A, and B gets 1 Point)
-to vote say the letter u wish to vote for.
-if u submitted a sig pls keep it private(and by private i mean keep it to urself) which is urs
- u may not vote your own sig!

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------


So heres place 1 to 3rd

Sigs:

A

Winner sig, made by Red
D

Second place sig, made by WindWaker aka MEH! :O
C

Third place sig, made by Shuji

I thought about letting the winner (Red) choose the render/theme of the next SOTW, if he agrees on it hah

We´ll see, ill make a new SOTW in one of the following days



Happy voting 

[Captn' Red]

This is how i would rate em ;P

D
C
B
A

So 2 points to D and one for C

[WindWaker]

A and C id say

[Aurix-kun]

A
D
C
B

[Hikaru]

where's the poll?

D,A,C,B.
B has rescaling, that's not the best thing to do.

[Karin]

CDAB

(isn't there some way to make this voting a bit less.. obvious? I mean.. Polls prevent people from showing what they actually will vote for..)

[Orion]

ABCD would be mine.... But a's is two tall by 50 pixles and should be disqualified. Sorry for whoever that is.

Now, as to why I chose who I did, here is a rundown from the bottom to top:

D's is a little too dark and muddied. you can't really see Saber with the background

C: would be nice, but the Korean really doesn't bring anything to the sig. In my opinion sigs really should be universally understood for everyone to understand them. also the color of saber is a bit darker then the original render so it looses some of it's detail. The background looks fine though.

B: A simple background, and Saber looks nice but a little on the chunky side. B needs to concentrate on making backgrounds more interesting.

A: it would be great if only A followed the rules of the Sig contest... 400x200 - it needed to be 400 x 150.

[Tragic]

These are good learning experiences. I'm liking these contests.

[WindWaker]

heh then ill keep them up i might work on some tutorials aswell ^_^

[Karo Rushe]

A
C
D
B

[Shuji]

ADBC.

True... A is too tall someone never read the rules.  hehe.

[WindWaker]

Current Points:

A: 11
B: 1
C: 5
D: 7

[Captn' Red]

Isn't it the hostess job to see if the contestands sig are the right size before it starts? ;p

[Shuji]

That is a good point... but I believe the contestants should read the rules and make good judgment before submitting their entry's. >: D

[Tragic]

I agree with Shuji. If someone's sig doesn't meet rules... Should it be disqualified or what?